Avaliação comportamental do processamento auditivo na idade adulta: população de interesse e testes - uma revisão sistemática / Behavioral assessment of auditory processing in adulthood: population of interest and tests - a systematic review

RESUMO Objetivo Identificar os testes comportamentais utilizados para a avaliação do processamento auditivo ao longo da vida adulta, com enfoque nas características da população alvo enquanto grupo de interesse. Estratégia de pesquisa As bases de dados consultadas foram o PubMed, CINAHL, Web of Science e Scielo, a partir dos descritores: "auditory perception" or "auditory perception disorders" or "auditory processing" or "central auditory processing" or "auditory processing disorders" or "central auditory processing disorders" com adults OR aging. Critérios de seleção Incluiu-se estudos com humanos, que abordaram a população adulta de 18 a 64 anos, que realizaram pelo menos um teste comportamental para avaliação do processamento auditivo, na ausência de perda auditiva. Análise dos dados Realizou-se a extração de dados de forma independente, a partir de um protocolo desenvolvido pelos autores incluindo diferentes tópicos, principalmente os testes auditivos comportamentais realizados e os resultados encontrados. Resultados Dos 867 registros identificados, 24 foram selecionados como contendo as informações necessárias para responder às perguntas de pesquisa. Conclusão Quase a totalidade dos estudos foi conduzida com objetivo de verificar o desempenho em um ou dois testes de processamento auditivo; a população alvo foi heterogênea, as mais frequentes foram diabetes, gagueira, transtorno do processamento auditivo e exposição ao ruído. Há poucas informações sobre os padrões de referência para os testes na respectiva faixa etária.

ABSTRACT Purpose To identify the behavioral tests used to assess auditory processing throughout adulthood, focusing on the characteristics of the target population as an interest group. Research strategies PubMed, CINAHL, Web of Science, and Scielo, databases were searched with descriptors: "auditory perception" or "auditory perception disorders" or "auditory processing" or "central auditory processing" or "auditory processing disorders" or "central auditory processing disorders" with adults OR aging. Selection criteria Studies with humans included, the adult population from 18 to 64 years old, who performed at least one behavioral test to assess auditory processing in the absence of hearing loss. Data analysis Data extraction was performed independently, using a protocol developed by the authors that included different topics, mainly the behavioral auditory tests performed and the results found. Results Of the 867 records identified, 24 contained the information needed to answer the survey questions. Conclusion Almost all studies were conducted verify performance in one or two auditory processing tests. The target target population was heterogeneous, with the most frequent persons with diabetes, stuttering, auditory processing disorder, and noise exposure. There is little information regarding benchmarks for testing in the respective age groups.

Valores normativos de pruebas conductuales de procesamiento auditivo para niños chilenos entre 7 y 12 años: una propuesta inicial / Normative values of auditory processing behavioral tests for chilean children between 7 and 12 years old: an initial proposal

Resumen Introducción: El trastorno del procesamiento auditivo en niños está relacionado con trastornos de lenguaje, bajo rendimiento académico, trastornos de aprendizaje y dificultades psicosociales. Existe consenso internacional sobre la utilidad de las pruebas conductuales para su evaluación y diagnóstico. Objetivo: Establecer valores normativos para pruebas conductuales de procesamiento auditivo en población pediátrica chilena con neurodesarrollo y audición normal. Material y Método: Se realizó un estudio observacional de corte transversal. Participaron 153 sujetos entre 7 y 12 años de la Región Metropolitana. Se estudiaron las pruebas de patrones de frecuencia, habla filtrada y dígitos dicóticos. Se construyeron modelos de regresión fraccional para estimar los valores normativos y además se calcularon los puntajes de corte en los percentiles 2.5, 5 y 10. Resultados: No se evidenciaron diferencias significativas entre oídos para las pruebas estudiadas a excepción de la prueba de dígitos dicóticos. Se construyeron modelos únicos para las pruebas patrones de frecuencia y habla filtrada, y modelos independientes para cada oído para la prueba dígitos dicóticos. Todas las estimaciones resultaron significativas y tuvieron niveles aceptables de precisión. Conclusión: Se obtuvieron los valores normativos y puntajes de corte para las tres pruebas estudiadas. Los valores obtenidos fueron similares a los reportados en otras poblaciones considerando los efectos de oído, de edad, sexo y escolaridad.

Abstract Introduction: Auditory processing disorder in children is related to language disorders, poor academic performance, learning disorders, and psychosocial difficulties. There is international consensus on the usefulness of behavioral tests for their evaluation and diagnosis. Aim: To establish normative values for auditory processing behavioral tests in Chilean pediatric population with normal neurodevelopment and hearing thresholds. Material and Method: An observational cross-sectional study was carried out. One hundred fifty-three subjects between 7 and 12 years old from the Metropolitan Region participated. Frequency pattern tests, filtered speech, and dichotic digits were studied. Fractional regression models were built to estimate the normative values, and cut-off scores were also calculated at the 2.5, 5, and 10 percentiles. Results: There were no significant differences between ears for the tests studied except for the dichotic digits test. Single models were built for the frequency and filtered speech patterns tests and independent models for each ear for the dichotic digit test. All estimates were significant and had acceptable levels of precision. Conclusion: The normative values and cut-off scores were obtained for the three tests studied. The values obtained were similar to those reported in other populations considering the effects of ear, age, sex, and education.

Evaluación electrofisiológica del procesamiento auditivo

Resumen En la actualidad existen distintas herramientas para la evaluación del procesamiento auditivo y sus alteraciones. Además de las pruebas conductuales y de las mediciones electroacústicas, se ha establecido que la batería mínima de evaluación del procesamiento auditivo debe incluir exámenes electrofisiológicos que permitan dar cuenta del estado funcional de las estructuras anatómicas a nivel de tronco cerebral, la corteza auditiva y del sistema nervioso auditivo central en general. Las pruebas electrofisiológicas más descritas en la literatura corresponden a las respuestas auditivas complejas de tronco cerebral, potenciales evocados auditivos de latencia media, potenciales evocados auditivos de latencia tardía, y los potenciales auditivos asociados a eventos como el potencial de disparidad y el P300. A pesar de que diversos organismos internacionales como la American Speech-Language-Hearing Association y la American Academy of Audiology han recomendado su utilización en el proceso diagnóstico del trastorno del procesamiento auditivo y han mencionado su utilidad en la diferenciación de cuadros asociados, no existe evidencia concluyente en relación con sus aplicaciones clínicas. Esto último ha llevado a organizaciones como la British Society of Audiology a poner en duda su verdadera utilidad en estos casos.

Abstract Currently, there are different tools for the assessment of auditory processing and its disorders. In addition to behavioral tests and electroacoustic measurements, it has been established that the minimum battery for auditory processing assessment must include electrophysiological examinations that allow to verify the functional state of anatomical structures at the brainstem, the auditory cortex and, broadly, the central auditory nervous system. In literature, the most described electrophysiological tests correspond to complex auditory brainstem responses, auditory middle latency evoked responses, auditory late latency evoked responses and event related evoked potentials, such as mismatch negativity and P300. Although several international organizations such as the American Speech-Language-Hearing Association and the American Academy of Audiology have recommended its use in the diagnostic process of auditory processing disorder and have mentioned its usefulness in the differentiation of associated conditions, there is no conclusive evidence in relation to its clinical applications. The latter has led organizations such as the British Society of Audiology to question its true usefulness in these cases.

Central Auditory Processing Tests as Diagnostic Tools for the Early Identification of Elderly Individuals with Mild Cognitive Impairment

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Mild cognitive impairment (MCI) is a disorder that usually occurs in the elderly, leading to dementia in some progressive cases. The purpose of this study is to examine the utility of central auditory processing tests as early diagnostic tools for identifying the elderly with MCI. SUBJECTS AND METHODS: This study was conducted on 20 elderly patients with MCI and 20 healthy matched peers. The speech perception ability in a quiet environment and in the presence of background noise and also temporal resolution were assessed by using Speech Perception in Noise (SPIN) and Gap in Noise (GIN) tests, respectively. RESULTS: The results indicated that the ability to understand speech in a quiet environment did not differ significantly between the two groups. However, SPIN at the three signal-tonoise ratios and the temporal resolution scores were significantly different between the two groups (p<0.001). CONCLUSIONS: Individuals with MCI appear to have poorer speech comprehension in noise and a lower temporal resolution than those of the same age, but without cognitive defects. Considering the utility of these tests in identifying cognitive problems, we propose that since the GIN test seems to be less influenced by intervening factors, this test can therefore, be a useful tool for the early screening of elderly people with cognitive problems.

Study of event-related potentials in school-age children with cleft palate / 口腔疾病防治

Objective @#To investigate possible functional disorders of central auditory processing and language in school-age children with cleft palate through an assessment of the characteristics of the P300 and N400 event-related potentials (ERPs). @*Methods @# This study included 28 school-age children with cleft palate, aged 6 to 12 years, and 30 children without cleft palate as a control group. The P300 and N400 ERPs were selected as indexes of the central auditory processing and language functions of children in both groups. The data were statistically compared between the two groups.@*Results @#Compared with the controls, the children with cleft palate showed a significantly prolonged P300 latency (331.73 ± 14.94 ms vs. 348.64 ± 14.66 ms, P < 0.05) and a significantly decreased P300 amplitude (13.47 ± 2.24 μV vs. 12.07 ± 2.46 μV, P < 0.05). Similarly, the N400 latency of children with cleft palate was significantly prolonged compared to that of controls (431.07 ± 17.90 ms vs. 408.23 ± 18.04 ms, P < 0.05), and the N400 amplitude was significantly decreased compared to that of controls (13.75 ± 2.12 μV vs. 15.17 ± 2.34 μV, P < 0.05). @* Conclusion@#School-age children with cleft palate may have central auditory processing disorders and language dysfunctions.

Perfil cognitivo de uma criança com diagnóstico prévio de dislexia do desenvolvimento associada a distúrbio do processamento auditivo central: estudo de caso / Cognitive Profile of a Child with Prior Diagnosis of Developmental Dyslexia Associated with Central Auditory Processing Disorder: Case Study

OBJETIVO: Este estudo fez uma análise comparativa do perfil cognitivo de uma criança com diagnóstico prévio de Dislexia do Desenvolvimento (DD) associada a Distúrbio do Processamento Auditivo Central, com perfis de DD descritos na literatura. MÉTODOS: Os domínios cognitivos da linguagem, memória, habilidades acadêmicas, percepção viso-motora, atenção, velocidade de processamento e funções executivas foram investigados por meio de uma bateria de testes neuropsicológicos. Paralelamente à testagem, foi realizada uma pesquisa bibliográfica sobre os perfis de DD descritos na literatura. RESULTADOS: Os resultados mostraram rebaixamento do Índice de Organização Perceptual em relação aos demais no WISC-IV. Os domínios da linguagem, habilidades acadêmicas e habilidades viso-espaciais mostraram-se deficitários quando comparados a crianças da mesma faixa etária e ao desempenho do próprio sujeito nos domínios da memória, atenção e funções executivas menos complexas. CONCLUSÃO: Em concordância com perfis de DD investigados na literatura, o perfil cognitivo do paciente confirmou: 1. Déficits no processamento fonológico. 2. Desempenho acadêmico com níveis rebaixados. 3. Disfunções executivas de planejamento, automonitoramento e raciocínio abstrato. 4. Dificuldades na formação, articulação e compreensão de conceitos verbais. 5. Erros ortográficos característicos e problemas específicos na leitura. 6. Dificuldades na memória de trabalho fonológica e memória semântica. 7. Memória episódica preservada. Divergindo de outros perfis descritos na literatura, este estudo mostrou: 1. Índice de Memória Operacional no WISC-IV dentro da faixa média. 2. Índice de Organização Perceptual rebaixado, na faixa limítrofe. 3. Comprometimento das habilidades viso-construtivas.

OBJECTIVE: This study had the purpose to do a comparative analysis of the cognitive profile of a child with prior diagnosis of Developmental Dyslexia (DD) associated with Central Auditory Processing Disorder, with the DD's profiles described in the literature. METHODS: The cognitive domains of language, memory, academic abilities, perceptual abilities, attention, speed processing and executive functions were investigated through a battery of neuropsychological tests. Additionally, a literature review about the cognitive profiles of DD was conducted. RESULTS: The results showed low Perceptual Reasoning Index in the WISC-IV. The domains of language, academic abilities and perceptual organization were limited comparing to other children at the same age and to the results of the patient in the domains of attention, memory and non-complex executive functions. CONCLUSION: In accordance with the DD profiles investigated in the literature, the patient's cognitive profile showed: 1. Phonological deficits. 2. Poor school achievement. 3. Executive dysfunctions related to planning, self-monitoring and abstract reasoning. 4. Problems in forming, articulating and understanding verbal concepts. 5. Characteristic reading and misspelling errors. 6. Deficits in the phonological working memory and semantic memory. 7. Episodic memory preserved. Differing from the profiles depicted in the literature, this study showed: 1. Working Memory Index in WISC-IV in normal levels. 2. Lowered Perceptual Reasoning Index. 3. Deficits in visual-perceptual skills.

Psychoacoustic Characteristics of Tinnitus versus Temporal Resolution in Subjects with Normal Hearing Sensitivity

Abstract Introduction Cochlear or neural mechanisms of tinnitus generation may affect auditory temporal resolution in tinnitus patients even with normal audiometry. Thus, studying the correlation between tinnitus characteristics and auditory temporal resolution in subjects with tinnitus may help in proper modification of tinnitus management strategy. Objective This study aims to examine the relationship between the psychoacoustic measures of tinnitus and the auditory temporal resolution in subjects with normal audiometry. Methods Two normal hearing groups with ages ranging from 20 to 45 years were involved: control group of 15 adults (30 ears) without tinnitus and study group of 15 adults (24 ears) with tinnitus. Subjective scaling of annoyance and sleep disturbance caused by tinnitus, basic audiological evaluation, tinnitus psychoacoustic measures and Gaps in Noise test were performed. Data from both groups were compared using independent sample t-test. Psychoacoustic measures of tinnitus and Gaps in Noise test parameters of the tinnitus group were correlated with Pearson's correlation coefficient. Results Significantly higher hearing threshold, higher approximate threshold and lower correct Gaps in Noise scores were observed in tinnitus ears. There was no significant correlation between psychoacoustic measures of tinnitus and Gaps in Noise test parameters of the tinnitus group. Conclusion Auditory temporal resolution impairment was found in tinnitus patients, which could be attributed to cochlear impairment or altered neural firing within the auditory pathway. It is recommended to include temporal resolution testing in the tinnitus evaluation battery to provide a proper management planning.

Temporal processing and long-latency auditory evoked potential in stutterers / Processamento temporal e potencial evocado auditivo de longa latência em indivíduos gagos

Abstract Introduction: Stuttering is a speech fluency disorder, and may be associated with neuroaudiological factors linked to central auditory processing, including changes in auditory processing skills and temporal resolution. Objective: To characterize the temporal processing and long-latency auditory evoked potential in stutterers and to compare them with non-stutterers. Methods: The study included 41 right-handed subjects, aged 18-46 years, divided into two groups: stutterers (n = 20) and non-stutters (n = 21), compared according to age, education, and sex. All subjects were submitted to the duration pattern tests, random gap detection test, and long-latency auditory evoked potential. Results: Individuals who stutter showed poorer performance on Duration Pattern and Random Gap Detection tests when compared with fluent individuals. In the long-latency auditory evoked potential, there was a difference in the latency of N2 and P3 components; stutterers had higher latency values. Conclusion: Stutterers have poor performance in temporal processing and higher latency values for N2 and P3 components.

Resumo Introdução: A gagueira é um distúrbio da fluência da fala e pode estar associada a fatores neuroaudiológicos ligados ao processamento auditivo central, entre eles as alterações das habilidades auditivas de processamento e resolução temporal. Objetivo: Caracterizar o processamento temporal e o potencial evocado auditivo de longa latência em indivíduos gagos e compará-los com indivíduos sem gagueira. Método: Participaram do estudo 41 indivíduos destros, de 18 a 46 anos, distribuídos em dois grupos: 20 com gagueira e 21 sem gagueira, comparados segundo idade, escolaridade e gênero. Todos os indivíduos foram submetidos aos testes de padrão de duração, teste de identificação de intervalos aleatórios e o potencial evocado auditivo de longa latência. Resultados: Indivíduos com gagueira apresentaram pior desempenho nos testes de padrão de duração e Random Gap Detection, quando comparados com os indivíduos fluentes. No potencial evocado auditivo de longa latência, houve diferença na latência dos componentes N2 e P3, os indivíduos gagos apresentaram maiores valores de latência. Conclusão: Os indivíduos com gagueira apresentaram processamento temporal com desempenho abaixo do esperado e um maior valor de latência para os componentes N2 e P3.

Auditory Processing Assessment in Children with Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder: An Open Study Examining Methylphenidate Effects

Abstract Introduction Children with Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder can present Auditory Processing (AP) Disorder. Objective The study examined the AP in ADHD children compared with non-ADHD children, and before and after 3 and 6 months of methylphenidate (MPH) treatment in ADHD children. Methods Drug-naive children diagnosed with ADHD combined subtype aging between 7 and 11 years, coming from public and private outpatient service or public and private school, and age-gender-matched non-ADHD children, participated in an open, non-randomized study from February 2013 to December 2013. They were submitted to a behavioral battery of AP tests comprising Speech with white Noise, Dichotic Digits (DD), and Pitch Pattern Sequence (PPS) and were compared with non-ADHD children. They were followed for 3 and 6 months of MPH treatment (0.5 mg/kg/day). Results ADHD children presented larger number of errors in DD (p < 0.01), and less correct responses in the PPS (p < 0.0001) and in the SN (p < 0.05) tests when compared with non-ADHD children. The treatment with MPH, especially along 6 months, significantly decreased the mean errors in the DD (p < 0.01) and increased the correct response in the PPS (p < 0.001) and SN (p < 0.01) tests when compared with the performance before MPH treatment. Conclusions ADHD children show inefficient AP in selected behavioral auditory battery suggesting impaired in auditory closure, binaural integration, and temporal ordering. Treatment with MPH gradually improved these deficiencies and completely reversed them by reaching a performance similar to non-ADHD children at 6 months of treatment.

A Comparative Study on Auditory Processing Abilities between Children with and without Learning Difficulties / 听力学及言语疾病杂志

Objective To study the auditory processing abilities of children with learning difficulty and deter-mine the proportion of the children with auditory processing disorder.Methods A single factor completely random-ized experimental design was used.Seventeen children with learning difficulties and 31 normal children from grade 2 to grade 4 in Beijing were induded in this study.The abilities of low-pass filtered speech,competing sentences,di-chotic digits and frequency patterns were tested through auditory processing disorder screening test software.Results There were significant differences in the abilities of listening sentences and digits in competitive environment and recognizing frequency patterns between children with learning difficulty and without.The auditory processing ability of children with learning difficulties was obviously poorer than normal children.The incidence of auditory processing disorder among the children with learning difficulties was 41.176%~58.824%.Conclusion The auditory process-ing ability in the competitive environment of children with learning difficulties was obviously poorer and they need in-tervention specifically.

Changes in Central Auditory Processing in Patients with Mesial Temporal Lobe Epilepsy after Anterior Temporal Lobectomy with Amygdalohippocampectomy

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: This study aimed to determine the effects of anterior temporal lobectomy with amygdalohippocampectomy (ATL-AH) on central auditory processing (CAP) in patients with mesial temporal lobe epilepsy with hippocampal sclerosis (mTLE-HS), and to identify factors that may contribute to the postoperative worsening of CAP. METHODS: Frequency-pattern, duration-pattern, and dichotic tests were performed before and after epilepsy surgery in 22 patients with normal hearing according to pure-tone audiometry. RESULTS: No significant difference in CAP scores was detected between pre- and postoperative tests, but there was a strong association between surgery in the language-dominant temporal lobe and postoperative worsening in the non-dominant-side dichotic test (p<0.05). The probability of a decreased performance in a non-dominant-side dichotic test after surgery was 7.5-fold greater in patients who underwent surgery on the dominant temporal lobe compared with the nondominant temporal lobe. No significant association of postoperative worsening in CAP with the verbal, nonverbal intelligence quotient, or right- or left-side lobectomy was noted. CONCLUSIONS: These results suggest that ATL-AH on the dominant side in patients with mTLE-HS worsens the CAP ability in the non-dominant-side dichotic test.

Effect of auditory training on the middle latency response in children with (central) auditory processing disorder

The purpose of this study was to determine the middle latency response (MLR) characteristics (latency and amplitude) in children with (central) auditory processing disorder [(C)APD], categorized as such by their performance on the central auditory test battery, and the effects of these characteristics after auditory training. Thirty children with (C)APD, 8 to 14 years of age, were tested using the MLR-evoked potential. This group was then enrolled in an 8-week auditory training program and then retested at the completion of the program. A control group of 22 children without (C)APD, composed of relatives and acquaintances of those involved in the research, underwent the same testing at equal time intervals, but were not enrolled in the auditory training program. Before auditory training, MLR results for the (C)APD group exhibited lower C3-A1 and C3-A2 wave amplitudes in comparison to the control group [C3-A1, 0.84 µV (mean), 0.39 (SD - standard deviation) for the (C)APD group and 1.18 µV (mean), 0.65 (SD) for the control group; C3-A2, 0.69 µV (mean), 0.31 (SD) for the (C)APD group and 1.00 µV (mean), 0.46 (SD) for the control group]. After training, the MLR C3-A1 [1.59 µV (mean), 0.82 (SD)] and C3-A2 [1.24 µV (mean), 0.73 (SD)] wave amplitudes of the (C)APD group significantly increased, so that there was no longer a significant difference in MLR amplitude between (C)APD and control groups. These findings suggest progress in the use of electrophysiological measurements for the diagnosis and treatment of (C)APD.

The Application of Diagnostic Tools of Central Auditory Processing Disorder and Their Normative Value in Each Age Group in Korean / 대한이비인후과학회지

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: To develop and apply a diagnostic test tool for central auditory processing disorder (CAPD) and to obtain normative data of Korean subjects with normal hearing. SUBJECTS AND METHOD: After obtaining the approvement of the Institution Review Board of Asan Medical Center for this clinical study, we conducted this study for 135 subjects with normal hearing. Frequency & duration pattern tests and dichotic test were administered to subjects with normal hearing were evaluated by pure tone audiometry. Patients were separated into the following age categories:up to and including 7-year-olds, 8- and 9-year-olds, 10- and 11-year-olds, 12- to 18-year-olds and adults over 18. RESULTS: The frequency pattern test showed that the mean score was 14.4+/-7.1, 19.7+/-9.2, 23.8+/-8.6, 24.1+/-7.0 and 28.5+/-2.7, for each age category, respectively. The duration pattern test showed that the mean score was 13.8+/-6.2, 17.0+/-6.1, 21.6+/-5.4, 25.6+/-4.3 and 28.4+/-2.1, respectively. The dichotic test showed that the right mean scores were 26.5+/-3.2, 27.0+/-3.2, 27.8+/-3.2, 29.4+/-0.9, 27.9+/-1.5 and left the mean scores 26.4+/-3.7, 27.0+/-2.6, 28.6+/-1.4, 28.6+/-1.3, 27.9+/-1.6 for each age category, respectively. CONCLUSION: We obtained the normative data of Korean subjects for the diagnosis of CAPD. Additional diagnostic tools and treatment methods must be developed continuously.